The Boathouse, Winona Lake, Indiana
Winona Lake is filled with an array of fish including perch, bluegill, cod, walleye. To no surprise, The Boathouse is known for its extensive seafood menu and fine dining. As a vegetarian in the fish house, I thought I would have a hard time finding something to eat that isn’t french fries or a head of lettuce. The Boathouse was more than a happy accident, it was fate. I stumbled upon a restaurant with fine dining, great service, and mouth-watering meals.
I discovered The Boathouse on a girls’ day out on the way back from a road trip to Ft. Wayne. Becoming delirious with hunger, the next stop became the stop to get lunch. Usually food-crazed decision making results in eating at some has-this-place-passed-health-inspection sort of restaurant, leaving you saying the same words as Job Bluth: “I’ve made a huge mistake.”
The entrance to the restaurant was impressive. It was modern, but not overly fancy. I still felt appropriately dressed in my jeans and nice shirt. Being seated immediately, our waitress promptly served us drinks as she nervously mentioned that it was her first day.
Again, I don’t eat meat. And yes, fish does count as meat in my book. I don’t buy into the Catholic idea of meat, and the fish on Fridays thing. So, finding a filling meal that I could eat is sometimes a daunting task. Thoughtfully, The Boathouse had marked each vegetarian friendly item with a “v,” making my search easier. Looking at the menu, I saw the typical vegetarian go-tos. There were veggie burgers and salads, but these didn’t seem like anything special.
Then, what caught my eye, was the Ravioli Espanol, “filled with mozzarella, parmesan, and ricotta cheese, over a scallion cream sauce.” It sounded good, but I was skeptical. This was a seafood restaurant after all. “You don’t go to a steakhouse and order a fish,” is a common phrase, except I was in the fish house ordering pasta. Well, how bad could it be?
Waiting for our meals to be prepared, our waitress made sure that our glasses were never empty. If she didn’t say this was her first day, you never would have guessed. She brought out our meal and I was again impressed by the efficient service.
The Ravioli Espanol was nothing I was expecting, but the plate was not disappointing in the slightest. It was plated beautifully, creating a flower shape around the dish with the center being a stack of cherry tomatoes marinated in a tangy balsamic vinaigrette. This was much different than the ravioli I was was expecting because each of the pieces were breaded and baked, encasing the creamy mozzarella and ricotta cheese inside. The ravioli paired perfectly with the balsamic tomatoes, enhancing the rich flavor of each ingredient.
The cream sauce with scallions on its own didn’t have much taste, but teamed with the balsamic, however, it allowed the taste of zesty vinaigrette to spread easily to the other parts of the plate, giving a balance between lush and piquant. With everyone who had fish on their plate asking to try a bite, the dish was the belle of the ball at my table. For a split second, I was embarrassed that I had doubted the integrity of my meal, but it quickly faded as satisfaction took its place. The vegetarian has succeeded in the fish house.
Being a vegetarian can sometimes be a headache when it comes to going out to eat. It can even cause you to leave a restaurant because there are no menu options. The Boathouse was genuine and accommodating, and on my next road trip I would gladly make the stop again. I was lucky my food-crazed decision making skills led me to The Boathouse.